NEL 1889 34 OSPITI ENTRARONO NELLA CASA DEI GEMELLI, MA NESSUNO È MAI STATO VISTO USCIRE
NEL 1889 34 OSPITI ENTRARONO NELLA CASA DEI GEMELLI, MA NESSUNO È MAI STATO VISTO USCIRE

FINE
Il bussare si ripeté. Tre colpi sordi si propagarono attraverso le assi del pavimento sotto gli stivali di William Carter.
Toc. Toc. Toc. La polvere tremava tra le assi. Il dottor James Warren sollevò la sua lanterna mentre gli altri uomini rimanevano immobili tra le diciannove figure avvolte in stoffa appese alle travi.
Fuori, da qualche parte, il vento soffiava tra i pini con un lungo e basso sibilo, ma dentro il capannone di essiccazione Carter riusciva a sentire solo il respiro: sette uomini spaventati che cercavano disperatamente di non respirare troppo forte.
Lo sceriffo Walter Grayson indietreggiò verso la porta. «Ce ne andiamo», disse. «Subito». Carter gli afferrò la manica.
«L’hai già sentito.» Grayson lo fissò. «In questa casa», continuò Carter. «La notte in cui hai soggiornato qui.»
“Hai sentito qualcosa sotto di te.” Il silenzio dello sceriffo gli rispose. Poi si udì un altro suono. Graffio.
Graffio. Graffio. Si muoveva sotto il pavimento da un’estremità all’altra del capannone.
Uno degli agenti alzò il fucile. Carter abbassò la lanterna verso le assi. Vicino alla parete di fondo, parzialmente nascosto sotto un banco da lavoro, notò un anello di ferro quadrato incastonato a filo nel pavimento.
Spostò la panca. Le sue gambe stridettero sulle assi. Una botola. «No», sussurrò Grayson.
Carter tirò l’anello. Un’aria fredda si levò verso l’alto portando con sé l’odore di terra bagnata, fumo e qualcosa di dolcemente marcio.
Sotto la porta, rozzi gradini di legno scendevano nell’oscurità. Carter prese la lanterna. Grayson gli afferrò il braccio.
“Se ci andate, passerete il resto della vostra vita a rimpiangerlo.”
Carter osservò le diciannove figure appese. “Trentaquattro persone sono venute qui”, disse. “Le loro famiglie meritano più che semplici auguri.”
Scese le scale. Queste gemettero sotto il suo peso. Warren lo seguì, poi il vice sceriffo Elias Mercer e altri due.
Grayson rimase in alto finché Carter non lo sentì imprecare a bassa voce e iniziare a scendere alle loro spalle. In fondo c’era un tunnel a malapena abbastanza largo per due uomini.
Le sue mura erano state scavate direttamente nella terra battuta e nella pietra. Travi di legno sostenevano il soffitto, e ganci erano stati conficcati in esse a intervalli regolari.
Alcuni ganci erano vuoti. Altri no. Carter continuava a guardare avanti. Il tunnel terminava in corrispondenza di un’altra porta.
Dall’altro lato si udirono tre colpi. Questa volta li sentirono tutti. Mercer alzò il revolver.
Carter aprì la porta. La stanza che si apriva era sorprendentemente grande. Gli scaffali ricoprivano le pareti dal pavimento al soffitto.
Su di essi erano appoggiate scarpe, orologi, occhiali, portafogli, giocattoli per bambini, lettere, anelli, coltelli, fotografie e decine di indumenti piegati con cura.
Non era un magazzino. Era un archivio. Trentaquattro piccole scatole di legno erano disposte lungo una parete.
Ognuno portava un nome. Henry Whitmore. Samuel Whitmore. Eleanor Shaw. La famiglia Bennett. Il dottor Warren si fermò accanto agli scaffali.
“Dear God.” Carter found the physician’s missing medical bag. Beside it sat a cracked pair of spectacles Carter recognized from a photograph supplied by another victim’s widow.
Then Mercer called from the opposite wall. “mr. Carter.” His voice had changed. There, carved directly into the timber, were thirty-four vertical marks.
Thirty-three had been crossed through. The final mark remained untouched. Beneath them someone had written:
THE LAST ONE OPENS THE DOOR. A floorboard creaked overhead. Everyone looked up. Another creak.
Then footsteps. Slow. Deliberate. Someone was walking through the curing shed above them. Carter counted automatically.
One set of footsteps. Then another. Grayson lifted his shotgun. “The twins,” he whispered. The lantern suddenly went out.
Darkness swallowed them. A gunshot exploded. Mercer screamed. Someone slammed into Carter, sending him against the wall.
Objects crashed from the shelves. A second shot flashed through the darkness, illuminating a human silhouette for less than a heartbeat.
Thin shoulders. Dark coat. Pale face. Then blackness again. Carter struck a match. For one trembling second the tiny flame revealed Edmund Hawthorne standing at the tunnel entrance.
Or Edward. There was no way to tell. The twin smiled. The match died. Carter lunged toward where the man had been, but heard boots pounding up the stairs.
“After him!” They climbed. Carter emerged into the curing shed and stopped. The nineteen hanging shapes were swaying.
Every one of them. Back and forth. Back and forth. But there was no wind.
The outer door stood open. Carter ran outside. Rain had begun falling, turning the yard black and slick.
A figure disappeared around the boarding house. Carter followed. Behind him came Mercer, Warren, Grayson, and the remaining deputies.
They rounded the house just as lightning tore across the mountains. For an instant the entire property turned white.
A man stood beside the hot spring. Then the darkness returned. “Stop!” Carter shouted. The figure ran.
Carter fired into the air. The man vanished behind the steam. They reached the spring seconds later.
Nothing. Only bubbling mineral water. Then Warren pointed. Across the clearing, another figure was standing beneath the trees.
Identical coat. Identical build. Identical face. The second twin. The deputies spread out. The man did not run.
Instead, he looked toward the house. And smiled. Flames appeared in an upstairs window. “Fire!”
Mercer shouted. Within seconds another window glowed orange. Then another. The boarding house erupted. Carter understood immediately.
The first twin had not been escaping. He had been buying time. “The records!” Carter sprinted toward the house.
Grayson tackled him before he reached the porch. “You go inside, you die!” “The ledger is in there!”
Warren pointed toward the abandoned wagon. “No. It isn’t.” The ledger still lay across its footboard.
Carter stopped struggling. Behind them, the second twin began laughing. It was a soft sound.
Almost affectionate. Grayson turned his shotgun toward him. “Where is your brother?” The man looked toward the burning house.
“Preparing supper.” Something crashed inside. Then came a scream. Not from the twins. A woman’s scream.
It rose from beneath the house. Every man froze. Another voice joined it. Then another.
Soon the burning structure seemed filled with voices—men, women, children—shouting beneath the roar of the flames.
Warren stepped backward. Carter stared at the twin. “What did you do to them?” The man tilted his head.
“We gave travelers what travelers always ask for.” “What?” “A place to stay.” The ground beneath the porch collapsed.
Fire shot upward. And from the opening came a sound Carter would remember until his death: dozens of voices exhaling together.
The twin suddenly ran. Grayson fired. The shot caught him in the shoulder and spun him into the mud.
Carter reached him first and rolled him onto his back. Blood spread beneath the man’s coat.
“Where is the other one?” The twin laughed. “Which other one?” “Your brother!” His smile widened.
“I never had a brother.” Carter stared at him. Behind them, Sheriff Grayson whispered, “No.”
The wounded man looked directly at the sheriff. Recognition passed between them. Grayson dropped his shotgun.
“When I came here last year,” he said, “I saw them together.” The man smiled again.
“You saw what we wanted you to see.” Lightning flashed. The clearing went white. For that instant Carter saw another man standing inside the upstairs window of the burning house.
The same face. The same smile. Then the roof collapsed. The wounded twin jerked once beneath Carter’s hands.
His eyes remained open. He was dead. The men stood in the rain until the house became a furnace.
They searched until dawn. They found no second body. But beneath the ruined house they discovered the answer to the knocking.
The underground chamber extended far beyond the curing shed. Iron pipes ran from the hot spring through the foundation, heating a network of narrow rooms hidden beneath the property.
Some contained beds. Others contained restraints. One chamber contained ten chairs. Ten. Exactly the number of guests from the final summer whose belongings had never been placed with the others.
All ten chairs were empty. On the wall were ten names. And beneath them: NOT YET FED.
Search parties spent the following three weeks combing the surrounding forest. They found the ten missing guests alive.
Barely. They had been confined inside an abandoned mining tunnel nearly two miles north of the property.
Some could no longer stand. Others could not remember their own names. But they survived.
Their testimony revealed how the Hawthorne House had operated. Travelers were drugged during supper. Those carrying money were robbed.
Some were imprisoned. Others never woke. The twins—or the men the survivors insisted were twins—had apparently maintained hidden tunnels between the house, curing shed, and an old mining passage.
Yet one detail could never be explained. Every rescued prisoner swore there were two Hawthorne brothers.
They had seen them together. Heard them speaking simultaneously. Watched one bring food while the other stood guard.
But the dead man recovered beside the hot spring was eventually identified as Edmund Hawthorne.
No record of Edward Hawthorne was ever found. No birth certificate. No property document. No photograph.
No signature. Every legal document connected with the boarding house contained Edmund’s name alone. Even stranger, handwriting experts later examined the guest ledger.
The entries supposedly written by two different brothers were made by the same hand. Authorities searched until the first heavy snow buried the mountains.
Edward was never found. The Hawthorne House was burned completely the following spring. The underground chambers were collapsed with explosives, and the property was closed.
Nathan Cole eventually left Pine Hollow. William Carter returned to logging. Dr. Warren never again ate meat.
Sheriff Grayson resigned before Christmas. The official investigation concluded that Edmund Hawthorne had murdered at least nineteen travelers and that an unidentified accomplice might have assisted him.
Carter never accepted that explanation. For the rest of his life he kept the original list of thirty-four names folded inside his Bible.
Thirty-four people had entered the Hawthorne property. Nineteen died. Ten were rescued from the mine.
Five others were eventually connected to remains recovered beneath the smokehouse. Thirty-four accounted for. The arithmetic was finally complete.
Almost. There remained the question of the twelve plates. Investigators initially assumed they had been prepared for the ten prisoners and the two brothers.
But according to the rescued captives, none of them had been inside the main house for weeks.
More troubling still, Edmund had supposedly been alone on the property when Thomas Reed arrived.
So who had prepared twelve places? No answer was ever found. Years later, Carter wrote a final account of the investigation.
Near the end he described something he had never included in his official statement. As the Hawthorne House burned that night, Carter had looked toward the upstairs window just before the roof collapsed.
He saw the second twin. But that was not what frightened him. Behind the man stood a dining table.
Around it sat people. Carter counted them. Ten guests. The second Hawthorne brother. And one empty chair.
Twelve places. Eleven occupied. The empty chair faced the window. Faced Carter. And as the flames climbed the walls, the second twin slowly pulled that chair away from the table.
As though inviting him to sit down. Carter never returned to the property. He died in 1903.
His family found the list of thirty-four names inside his Bible, just as he had promised.
But there was something else written beneath them in Carter’s handwriting. A thirty-fifth name. His own.
E accanto ad esso c’era lo stesso piccolo segno orizzontale che era apparso accanto al nome di Samuel Whitmore sedici anni prima.
PAGATO PER INTERO.
Avvertenza: questa storia è interamente di fantasia ed è stata creata esclusivamente a scopo di intrattenimento.
Non rappresenta alcuna organizzazione o individuo, né promuove o incoraggia comportamenti inappropriati.