Uncategorized

Au coeur de l’école la plus malsaine des USA : les expériences médicales de Willowbrook

In 1947, the worst school in the United States opened. Imagine a place where thousands of vulnerable children were locked up, abused, and even used as guinea pigs for medical experiments.

This place really existed; it was called Willowbrook. Behind the walls of this school, which is supposed to welcome and protect children with mental disabilities, hell awaits them.

Left virtually abandoned in catastrophic sanitary conditions, these children were to be the guinea pigs for medical experiments now considered scandalous. For decades, all of this took place in the utmost secrecy, at least until the day the truth finally came out.

Today, I’m going to tell you about the ordeal of the children of Willowbrook. To understand how Willowbrook became one of the biggest human scandals in the United States, we must first go back to its creation.

The story begins in 1947 on Staten Island, in the state of New York. That year, the authorities opened a gigantic establishment called Willowbrook State School.

The buildings have existed since 1942, but they were dedicated to this school project only in 1947. Well, on paper, the objective is rather laudable.

The aim is to welcome children with disabilities, intellectual impairments, and to offer them a suitable environment. There, we could provide them with care, specialized education adapted to their abilities, their level of autonomy, and so on.

Some might even attend courses that are slightly tailored to their progress. Others could take part in activities that could stimulate them, that sort of thing.

In short, it’s the ideal establishment. Because yes, at that time, knowledge about mental disability was still very limited; it was a very little-known subject.

Families are often left on their own; they have no idea how to manage, how to develop the potential of a child with a disability. In short, the resources that exist today did not exist at all.

In addition to that, their future is quite uncertain. The disabilities that affect them sometimes require daily care, prevent them from living alone even as adults, prevent them from working, and so on.

And obviously, at the time, support solutions were rare. Many children live in isolation, sometimes even hidden away by their relatives for fear of how others will see them.

So, naturally, institutions like Willowbrook appear as an almost miraculous solution. It would be a place where children could live surrounded by professionals, and other children too, to best develop their abilities.

So, in the end, many families are ready to sign without really knowing where their children will be going. Built on several hectares, the center consists of several buildings including dormitories, treatment rooms, dining halls, but also spaces dedicated to classes and activities.

Enough to accommodate approximately 4000 residents. 4000 is enormous and at the time made Willowbrook the largest venue for this audience.

From the very first years, the institution was indeed presented as a success. Children are cared for there, there is staff, financial resources, and new equipment.

Registrations are happening en masse and the place is seen as a real step forward in the care of people with disabilities. But very quickly, a major problem appears which will slowly lead the establishment to its downfall and transform it into a veritable hell.

Very quickly, applications for admission to Willowbrook skyrocketed. More and more children are being referred to this place, which is unfortunately one of the few places that offers this type of support.

And so, instead of the 4000 residents originally planned, there were eventually 4500, then 5000 and even exceeded 6000 residents in the 1960s, which far exceeded the maximum capacity of the place.

The dormitories quickly became overcrowded and some photos from that time show children sharing a bed between two, or even more. And in parallel with that, the staff is not increasing at the same rate.

Very quickly, the employees find themselves completely overwhelmed, whereas initially three or four adults are supposed to take care of ten or at most fifteen children, given that they really need individualized care, but in the end the number of children for one employee quickly triples, or even quadruples.

In the end, nearly 70 residents are cared for by only two or three poorly trained and overworked employees. At that point, it becomes completely impossible to provide the necessary care and attention.

Residents spend the majority of their time in large dormitories or common rooms. Some children spend their entire day without stimulation, simply sitting or lying down for hours.

No one communicates with them and their days follow one another, all similar. At that point, the place was no longer a school in name only, since the educational activities, which had been promised when the project was created, disappeared completely.

Obviously, the staff is so understaffed that they are now focusing more on the survival of the residents than on developing their abilities. But a much more serious problem will develop precisely because of the overpopulation of the place.

These are the sanitary conditions. With the number of residents constantly increasing, hygiene becomes extremely difficult to maintain.

Professionals no longer even know which children can feed themselves or not, which ones need help going to the toilet. In short, in the end, the children are practically abandoned and the sanitary conditions are deteriorating more and more.

One thing leading to another, unsurprisingly, they all start getting sick. Because yes, diseases spread easily in overcrowded dormitories and the lack of hygiene doesn’t help, quite the opposite.

And yet, the school, if we can still call it a school, continues to operate and to welcome ever more children. But then what? Firstly, because outside of the city, Willowbrook’s image remains relatively positive.

For many families, the institution remains one of the only options available for their children. And the authorities, well, for their part, they clearly prefer to ignore the problems.

Years go by and the situation deteriorates even further. At this point, Dr. William Bronston, who is a physician at the facility, describes Willowbrook as a kind of human warehouse.

I find this very telling in understanding the level of dehumanization of children. In fact, they were simply stored there like cattle.

But what everyone doesn’t know at this point is that Willowbrook isn’t just going to become a kind of warehouse for human beings. The institution will also become the scene of truly inhumane and scandalous medical experiments.

Because ultimately, in these buildings where thousands of vulnerable children live, some researchers see a real opportunity to test things that would help advance science. And for several years, these experiments will be conducted while families and the whole world still do not know what is really happening behind the walls of the institution.

Inevitably, Willowbrook’s story will continue to grow darker. Okay, let’s recap.

By the end of the 1950s, Willowbrook was already far, far from being the promised school that took care of children with disabilities. And adults too, right, because there were also adults and teenagers who were being cared for.

The buildings are overcrowded, hygiene conditions are deteriorating, and infections are multiplying. And indeed, there is a virus that will spread rapidly and infect almost everyone.

This is hepatitis. To summarize, there are five main viruses: hepatitis A, B, C, D and E.

Hepatitis A, B and C are the most widespread today, but this was not known in the 1950s. In fact, it was not even known that there were several types of hepatitis.

It is also important to know that hepatitis has caused some of the deadliest epidemics in the world. It is a virus that affects the liver; it can be more or less serious, it can be chronic, but overall, the symptoms are as follows.

First, a yellowing of the skin. I believe that’s why we used to talk about jaundice when in reality it was a symptom of hepatitis.

Experts, feel free to chime in with your comments. Other symptoms include fatigue, fever, nausea or even vomiting, abdominal pain, and gradually the disease damages the liver, sometimes causing cirrhosis, sometimes cancer, and sometimes, of course, death.

Okay, I’ve summarized a lot and not all hepatitis viruses cause exactly the same symptoms, but this is simply to help you get a little better idea of the disease. At that time, researchers did not really understand how the virus was transmitted or why some people developed severe symptoms while others eventually recovered.

That’s when Dr. Saul Krugman will have an idea. He’s a doctor who works in Willowbrook and he’s very keen to better understand the virus so he can treat it.

And so, he is faced with thousands of defenseless children, most of whom are already infected due to the sanitary conditions in Willowbrook. And yes, the children live on top of each other, they share the same bathrooms, the same dormitories and cleanliness is clearly relegated to the back burner.

As a result, a large proportion of the residents end up contracting hepatitis at some point. And it is precisely this observation that will serve as justification for the horror.

As you have understood, instead of improving the living conditions of the residents to limit the spread of the disease, our dear Dr. Krugman decided to study them in order to better understand the symptoms. Well then, this is already a really unethical decision, but it doesn’t stop there.

Krugman and his team’s reasoning is quite simple. According to them, since the majority of children in Willowbrook end up being infected with hepatitis anyway, it makes sense to observe the disease in a controlled setting.

In other words, they want to deliberately cause the infection in order to be able to study precisely the evolution of the virus. Yes, yes, you understood correctly, they are going to make perfectly healthy children sick, children who are incapable of giving or withholding their consent for anything.

The aim is to observe what happens in the body from the first days of infection, how the virus develops, how long it takes for symptoms to start to appear and above all how the body reacts to the disease. Well, you must be thinking that even back then, permits would have been needed to conduct such experiments, and you’re right.

But they’ve already had them. Firstly, from the pediatric center in New York, but also from the families who placed their children in Willowbrook.

How could a parent accept that their own child could be infected with a potentially dangerous disease? To obtain their agreement, Dr. Krugman sent them a very well-written letter which read: “We are currently investigating the possibility of preventing hepatitis epidemics with a new method.

We would like to give your child this new form of prevention in the hope that they will be protected afterwards. If you wish to give your child the benefit of this new preventative method, you can sign this document.” And yes, at no point does he specify that some children could die from the disease.

He talks to parents about protecting their children as if it were a real chance to make the residents immune. Basically, the message was “Hepatitis is already widespread in Willowbrook, so we might as well take advantage of it to vaccinate the children” as if there were no risk.

Well, let’s be honest, we know that the research will take years. The vaccine trials and experiments conducted at that time may indeed one day benefit future generations, but at that time the children used were simply undergoing the tests and sometimes even dying from them.

Worse than that, some parents testify several years later and claim that they had virtually no choice but to allow the experiments on their children under threat of not allowing them to enter school. Because yes, let’s remember that at that time Willowbrook still had a good reputation, it makes you wonder how it’s possible, but what was happening inside the walls wasn’t really known to the general public.

So families are completely destitute and continue to apply to put their child in Willowbrook. The waiting list is very long and for some parents, allowing the experiments seemed mandatory to get a place.

Some even testify that they were promised their child would receive an antidote for hepatitis if they agreed to have them participate in the experiment. In short, once the permits are in hand, the experiments begin.

But then, how do they manage to infect them? First, Dr. Krugman’s team will select a group of children whom they will isolate from the others.

And by observing children already infected with the disease, they realize that hepatitis seems to be transmitted through bodily fluids, so blood, saliva, feces, that sort of thing. They will therefore naturally bring the food of healthy residents into contact with various bodily fluids in order to contaminate them.

The example often cited in the scientific articles I have read is the mixture of infected fecal matter with chocolate milk which was then given to healthy children to drink. The idea is to reproduce what researchers thought was the natural mode of transmission of the virus, if we don’t wash our hands, if we contaminate food, and so on.

Between the 1950s and the early 1970s, hundreds of children participated in hepatitis studies conducted at Willowbrook. For more than 10 years, these experiments will take place within the walls of the center.

And with each new trial, each new result on a group of infected children, Dr. Krugman publishes his conclusions in medical journals. Meanwhile, children are dying, living conditions in Willowbrook remain catastrophic, and some children are clearly malnourished.

And yet, since everything is happening behind closed doors, nobody says anything. So, despite the horrors that are happening there, Dr. Krugman’s experiments were not in vain.

It is thanks in particular to his research that the strains of hepatitis A and B, which do not cause the same symptoms and do not have the same severity, have been brought to light. Basically, he’s the first one who manages to differentiate between the two, you know.

Similarly, Krugman’s research undoubtedly accelerated the development of a vaccine against hepatitis B. But against which one?

One might think that the whole world would have condemned these experiments on children, but in reality, many were completely unaware of what was happening within the Willowbrook compound. Nevertheless, some members of the medical profession protested against the experiments conducted by Krugman.

But unfortunately, it didn’t gain enough traction to generate publicity for the center. At least, until the mid-1960s.

Because yes, in 1965, an official visit would mark a turning point. That year, a senator decided to visit Willowbrook to see for himself the living conditions of the residents.

This is Robert Kennedy, the brother of John Fitzgerald Kennedy, and he is going to leave the establishment horrified. As he walks through the institution’s building, Kennedy is in shock.

He sees children left to their own devices, in rags or naked, sitting on the ground with nothing to do for hours, sometimes sitting in their own excrement. And it’s important to remember that at that point, the place had already been open for 20 years.

Some residents have been enduring this for more than ten years. In some rooms, the smells are so strong that visitors find it difficult to stay for more than a few minutes.

The rooms are packed with children or adults who have been staring blankly for hours, giving visitors a profound sense of unease. They may also realize that there are so few healthcare professionals that they have to leave the children almost entirely to their own devices.

After seeing what was happening at Willowbrook, Robert Kennedy did not hide his indignation and he even went to speak to the press. He describes the place as, and I quote, “a veritable viper’s nest where thousands of children live in filth and squalor.”

For him, it is not the staff within the establishment that is at fault, but the managers who do not provide enough resources to properly care for the residents. At this moment, it is the very first time that Willowbrook is put a little bit in the spotlight.

And yet, despite the public revelation, the affair almost immediately fell back into obscurity. Willowbrook remains open and nothing changes.

The children continue to live there in extremely difficult conditions. So, at that time and for several years afterward, most Americans were completely unaware of what was really going on behind the walls of that institution.

It wasn’t until the early 1970s that the truth truly came out, as a journalist managed to enter Willowbrook with a camera and the images he filmed there caused one of the biggest scandals in the history of the United States. The year is 1972, 25 years after the school opened.

Geraldo Rivera, a reporter for a New York network, had already heard about Willowbrook 7 years earlier during Kennedy’s visit, but like everyone else, this story was very quickly forgotten. Until the day he was contacted by a doctor working directly at the center.

This is Michael Wilkins, and what he is about to tell her will immediately pique her curiosity. But to understand what is really happening in Willowbrook, Geraldo knows he cannot rely solely on interviews and documents.

We need to show images. So, he organizes an initial visit to the establishment with a discreet camera.

And what he discovers inside surpasses anything he could have imagined. According to Geraldo, Willowbrook has not changed at all since the senator’s visit, quite the opposite.

The conditions are still just as deplorable, staff are dwindling due to lack of budget, the situation is catastrophic and this absolutely must be brought to light. But strangely, just after he filmed his first images in building 6 that you just saw, Geraldo was contacted by the school’s leaders to return two days later.

And there, obviously, the setting is completely different. There are more staff, they are attentive to the children, they even hold them in their arms.

All the residents are dressed, in the images it even looks like they just turned on the light, although I think it’s also the camera that does that, but oh well. But obviously, the difference between the two visits is striking.

Geraldo is not fooled and suspects that this is simply a staged event intended to hide the true living conditions of the residents. Then, two days later, he returned again and filmed more terrible images.

This time, moreover, in a different building. There, it’s certain, there is no longer any doubt, all the buildings, all the residents are affected by the horror he saw.

Geraldo explains in his report that the condition of the residents may suggest that it is impossible to give them lessons, to help them progress, but in reality, it is precisely the isolation to which they are subjected, the context, the lack of care and communication that makes them so apathetic. If you were locked up for years in this kind of isolated place, in silence, with the cries of the other residents, with nothing else to do but wait for the hours and days to pass, you too would probably be in the same state after several years.

We also learn, during the report, that where in theory children are supposed to have 20, or even 30 minutes one-on-one with a professional to help them eat, this time is now reduced to only two or three timed minutes due to a lack of staff. They must gulp down their meal as if they were stuffed, and if they don’t eat their fill, too bad for them.

The same applies if they have difficulty eating. Far from being satisfied with this single establishment as an example, Geraldo Rivera will also visit Letchworth Village, which is located not far from Willowbrook.

This is also a center specializing in the care of children and adults with disabilities whose living conditions are unfortunately almost identical to those of Willowbrook. Despite the visit to this other place scheduled for 10am, Geraldo must have had a hunch and he prefers to come on site and start filming 2 hours before the meeting.

As if by chance, shortly before 10am, the originally scheduled time, bags of clothes were brought to dress the children, and household products were brought out to clean up the mess, but obviously it was too late; the images filmed a few hours earlier did not lie. A professional on site will be interviewed and will explain that if some residents remain naked inside the premises, without privacy and without blankets despite the cold and the stares, it is essentially because the facility simply does not have enough clothes or enough staff to dress everyone.

We also learn that in this center, some residents who are more independent than others are supposed to be able to work. Working outside the office, basically.

So that really shows the level of autonomy some people have. And yet, despite that, they were forced to work on site, replacing the insufficient number of employees.

They were paid $2 a week, the equivalent of what they could have earned per hour working off-premises. Under the name Willowbrook The Last Great Disgrace, which can be translated as the last disgrace or the last shame, the report was finally broadcast in 1972 and the impact was immediate.

Viewers are seeing footage shot inside the facility for the first time, and obviously for many Americans, it’s a shock. They didn’t even dare to imagine that such a place could exist.

What they see on the screen looks less like a care center and more like a prison. And besides, in prison they have more space and privacy.

Some media outlets will even go so far as to describe conditions reminiscent of concentration camps. At that moment, of course, the scandal immediately erupted.

The media have taken up the case, human rights organizations have denounced the situation and above all, well, families of former residents are starting to tell a little bit about what their children experienced at Willowbrook. Faced with media and public pressure, the authorities of the State of New York can no longer ignore the situation.

Legal proceedings were immediately initiated to denounce the living conditions in the institution, and finally, things began to move. In 1975, the State committed to improving the living conditions of residents, reducing overcrowding and developing alternatives for the care of disabled people.

But in practice, ultimately, changes take time and despite these decisions, the situation remains difficult for several years. Families and associations continued to mobilize until finally, Willowbrook closed its doors for good.

After years of scandal, the decision was made: Willowbrook officially closed in 1987. It took 40 years of neglect, abuse, and controversial experimentation for the institution to finally cease to exist.

But the Willowbrook case does not disappear and will have many consequences for the future. Some children who were placed in Willowbrook were able to testify, and still testify today, about the hell they experienced.

Today, fortunately, specialized institutions are more regulated. Specific professions have emerged to better support people with disabilities.

But we must not forget that in Willowbrook, many suffered violence or abuse that will mark them for life, while some even lost their lives because of mistreatment, illnesses or experiments carried out at the center. Dr. Krugman, meanwhile, was rewarded for his work at Willowbrook.

This was only the beginning of his brilliant career, as he later became head of the pediatrics department at the New York University School of Medicine. He was elected to the National Academy of Sciences and he wrote a reference manual on pediatric infectious diseases.

For your information, he defended the Willowbrook experiments his whole life, even writing in 1986, and I quote, “I am as convinced today as I was then that our studies were ethical and justifiable.” He finally passed away in 1995.

Today, his son still defends his father, convinced that he wanted to do good, advance science and ultimately enable the discovery of a vaccine. In 1974, a national research law was passed to establish regulations protecting participants in clinical trials.

One of the measures implemented was, in particular, the creation of a working group on ethics. As for the Willowbrook site itself, it still exists.

A large part of the building has been repurposed and now houses the College of Staten Island. But some areas of the old complex remained closed, left to decay.

Finally, it was as if part of this place still bore traces of its past. Ultimately, the story of Willowbrook leaves behind a true paradox.

On one hand, some research at Willowbrook has genuinely contributed to advancing medicine. Studies on hepatitis have helped scientists to better understand the disease, to distinguish different types of viruses and, later, to develop the vaccine that has helped protect millions of people.

But on the other hand, all this was done at the cost of extremely vulnerable children, unable to understand what was happening to them and who did not even have the power to consent or not to what was being done to them. So, is it acceptable to sacrifice lives to potentially save others?

Some will say that yes, obviously, the doctors and researchers who worked at Willowbrook did not feel they were doing wrong. This is what is called rationalization; they ended up convincing themselves that their actions were justified.

But when we reason like that and we don’t have the safeguard of morality and ethics, where do we go? Because we can quickly end up creating hells like Willowbrook.

Thank you for watching this video to the end. Feel free to give a thumbs up if you found this topic interesting.

You can also boost the video to make it stand out. And don’t hesitate to subscribe to see the rest of the videos.

As for me, I’ll see you very soon and until then, take care.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

You Might Also Enjoy